This is a useful demonstration of the tension that security design analysis must sometimes grapple with. Applying stride perelement to the diagram shown in figure e1. The skills, techniques and repertoire can all be learned. Hes been a threat modeling advocate for years, and has been blogging a lot about our new processes, and describes in great detail the stride per element process. We just consider two element types for the stride analysis. Effects analysis extends fmea with threat modes and vulnerabilities. Repudiation is unusual because its a threat when viewed from a security perspective, and a desirable property of some privacy systems, for example, goldbergs off the record messaging system. For instance, stride is a wellknown threat analysis technique that is also used in the automotive domain. Online banking security analysis based on stride threat model. The stride model is a useful tool to help us classify threats. Some threats are listed by stride, others are addressed in less structured text.
Sep 11, 2007 they all have some exposure to security, but terms that ive been using for years are often new to them. Optimize security mitigation effectiveness using stride. Stride is a model of threats developed by praerit garg and loren kohnfelder at microsoft for identifying computer security threats. Thus, threat modeling can be used as part of requirements engineering to derive security requirements, based on a first architecture overview, or threat modeling can be used as a design analysis technique.
The stride per element approach to threat modeling. This security threat analysis has important significance for the online banking system. Increasingly, rigor is being demanded and applied to the security risk assessment process and subsequent risk treatment plan. Applying stride perelement to the diagram shown in figure e1 acme would rank the threats with a bug bar, although because neither the bar nor the result of such ranking is critical to this example, they are not shown.
Physical security risk assessment of threats including that from terrorism need not be a black box art nor an intuitive approach based on experience. They all have some exposure to security, but terms that ive been using for years are often new to them. Stride shall support research capacity building as well as basic, applied and transformational action research that can contribute to national prioritiers with focus on inclusive human development. Section2 discusses analyzing a dfd for wellformedness. Introduction to microsoft security development lifecycle sdl. This current document presents an architectural threat analysis of.
Portable document format pdf security analysis and. Threat modeling, also called architectural risk analysis, is a security control to identify and reduce risk. Hackers are using new techniques to gain access to sensitive data, disable applications and administer other malicious activities aimed at the software application. Threat analysis for hardware and software products using hazop. Larry osterman is a longtime ms veteran, currently working in windows audio.
Impact, the potential damage physical, logical, monetary loss, etc of a threat event. Microsoft threat modeling tool the microsoft threat modeling tool makes threat modeling easier for all developers through a standard notation for visualizing system components, data flows, and security boundaries. Your perception of how well you are protected is only as good as the information you collect, and many organizations struggle with collecting the right information. Dread and stride analysis for identification of threats and their risk rating in the trinity wallet. Uncover security design flaws using the stride approach.
Request pdf security analysis of smartphone using stride abstract this paper addresses the security domain of smart phones pertaining to major vulnerabilities. Threat modeling in enterprise architecture integration. Sep 19, 2016 which threat risk model is right for you. A biomechanical analysis of the last stride, touchdown, and. Different approaches of security analysis were considered, such as attacktrees, stride, dread and security design principles. By combining stride with attack tree approaches 12, we provide a.
Stride variants and security requirementsbased threat analysis. A process to ensure application security by steven burns october 5, 2005. It is also a true programming language of its own, strongly dedicated to document creation and manipulation which has accumulated a lot of. By applying this method to the online banking system threat analysis, we construct stride threat model on the analysis of the key business data, and then we. Department of defenses fvap federal voting assistance program. Its the business goal as the customer stated it, but you need to turn the problem statement into specifications and plans. Caststride an approach of bringing safety and security. A security analysis of the secure electronic registration. Application threat modeling using dread and stride is an approach for analyzing the security of an application. Analysis process to analysis store here we encounter an interesting situation regarding tampering. Online banking security analysis based on stride threat.
Security must be among these and present from the start, becoming built in rather than bolted on. Pdf a stride model based threat modelling using unified and. It provides a mnemonic for security threats in six categories. A biomechanical analysis of the last stride, touchdown. Sep 24, 2017 big picture riskmanagementbusiness financial information security disaster it. Section ii summarises related work in the area of sdn security analysis. The choice fellon stride, because it seemed promising, using keywordsand basing its analysis on data flow diagrams. Similar to stride, this method is a mnemonic, meaning the threat categories in question are coded in the method name. The combined analysis of both threat assessment vectors impacts established an overall threat likelihood. However, it is particularly important for design analysis and testing, where it motivates and underlies. Threat modeling with stride slides adapted from threat modeling.
In order to assess the security of a system, we must therefore look at all the possible threats. This paper refers important issues regarding how to evaluate the security threats of the online banking effectively, a system threat analysis method combining. Jul 02, 2019 stride will provide support to research projects that are socially relevant, locally needbased, nationally important and globally significant. Stridebased security model in acme carnegie mellon university. Advantages available in an early design phase dfd is not essential it can also be used by a nonexpert of threat analysis with knowledge database of a security analysis graph disadvantages require relatively long time if there is no knowledge database of a security. Threat risk modelling mainly comprises the following steps.
Stride 5, for instance, is a security analysis method based on decomposing the system and iteratively analyzing its parts. Pdf an approach to threat modeling in web application. It also helps threat modelers identify classes of threats they should consider based on the structure of their software design. Threat analysis overview threatagent a,acker targetsystem threatexploitsvulnerabili. Stride will provide support to research projects that are socially relevant, locally needbased, nationally important and globally significant. Thus it gives a detailed threat analysis of the online banking system. Subsequently, section iii presents the results of the stride application to current sdn concepts. We describe how a generic voice assistant application works with a data ow diagram. It is a structured approach that enables you to identify, classify, rate, compare and prioritize the security risks associated with an application. Portable document format pdf security analysis and malware. For both types, we omit the threats repudiation and information disclosure, because they do not directly in. Strides acronym is spoofing tampering repudiation information disclosure denial of service elevation of privilege we have learnt about the security properties in earlier class, they are. The security risk assessment methodology sciencedirect. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
We perform a highlevel, extensible and adaptable security analysis of openflow protocol and network setups, using the stride 11 vulnerability modeling technique. Designing for security wiley, 2014 by adam shostack wouldnt it be beher to. Applying strideperelement to the diagram shown in figure e1. Threat modeling overview threat modeling is a process that helps the architecture team. Application security has become a major concern in recent years. Stride has been successfully applied to cyberonly and cyberphysical systems. Portable document format pdf security analysis and malware threats abstract adobe portable document format has become the most widespread and used document description format throughout the world. Well then go over an example of the two being used together. Once the different subsystems have been delimited and their interactions identified, they are matched against the six stride vectors. In this lesson, well take a look at the idea of a threat model, what it is, what stride is and how the two are related. We have a data flow contained entirely within a trust boundary. Onfs security principles and practices document 3 focuses on the general security principles for the sdn architecture and provides a deep security analysis with regard to the openflow switch specification protocol version 1. Accurately determine the attack surface for the application assign risk to the various threats drive the vulnerability mitigation process it is widely considered to be the one best method of improving the security of software.
Introduction to microsoft security development lifecycle sdlthreat modeling. As a security architect, i want to do a threat model of so that i can design effective security controls mitigate the threats identi. Although microsoft no longer maintains stride, it is implemented as part of the microsoft security development lifecycle sdl with the threat modeling tool, which is still available. Pdf stridebased threat modeling for cyberphysical systems. Infotechs mitigation effectiveness assessment provides the insight required to make good business and risk management decisions. By using an adapted stride approach, we analyze the pattern diagrams to list the security threats for each of the patterns. The primary focus of that directive is to help ensure that microsofts windows software developers think about security during the design phase. Pdf threat modeling for automotive security analysis. We then use the stride approach 10 for categorizing 16 identi ed threats and the dread model. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. The paper identifies that stride is a lightweight and effective threat modeling methodology for cps that simplifies the task for security analysts. The stride threat model helps place threats into categories so that questions can be. Microsoft security development lifecycle threat modelling. Pdf online banking security analysis based on stride threat.
We provide a security analysis based on the sdl threat modeling methodology. Security analysis of smartphone using stride request pdf. Caststride an approach of bringing safety and security together. A system theoretic approach to cybersecurity risk analysis. In this post, we take a look at threat modeling and the use of stride as a threat classification model that is used for security development. In this situation, a hardcore security theorist might say theres absolutely no need to worry about processes entirely within a trust boundaryafter all, you trust them. Control a safeguard or countermeasure to avoid, detect, counteract, or minimize security risks to information, computer systems, or other assets. A stridebased security architecture for softwarede.
A summary of available methods sei digital library. Threat modeling and analysis of voice assistant applications. Stridebased threat modeling for cyberphysical systems. Which threat risk model is right for your organization. Threat modeling in enterprise architecture integration as integrated systems are becoming more complex, vulnerability analysis is crucial to assess and safeguard against threats enterprise architecture integration eai has matured over the years to enable limitless information sharing across the globe and across a multitude of platforms. Ways to find security issues stac analysis of code. Advantages available in an early design phase dfd is not essential it can also be used by a nonexpert of threat analysis with knowledge database of a security analysis graph disadvantages require relatively long. Stride variants and security requirementsbased threat. Strides main issue is that the number of threats can grow rapidly as a system increases in complexity. Threat analysis techniques facilitate a systematic analysis of the attackers profile, visavis the assets of value to the organization 18.
232 309 1074 317 836 692 1276 477 1554 308 1561 748 1062 369 198 1236 560 1031 513 41 825 158 893 371 1418 1034 1184 1062 1080 16 206 1101 689